|
Post by rikiiboy on Jul 5, 2024 10:59:01 GMT
|
|
|
Post by marispiper on Jul 5, 2024 14:04:31 GMT
I am whacked out, staying up late then getting up early. The low turnout speaks volumes about disenchantment.
We shall see what Starmer comes up with in the days ahead... today he's just schmoozing. I do hope for all our sakes that positive steps are in there.
Q: How do fewer votes translate to more seats? I do know the answer - but something is radically wrong there and it needs fixing.
Sad someone decent like Jonathan Ashworth should lose his seat to an independent standing only on the Gaza vote with no interest in the betterment of the country. Jess Phillips and Shabana Mahmood's victory speeches were drowned out by more protests from the religion of peace and accusations of 'infidel'
|
|
|
Post by hild1066 on Jul 5, 2024 16:37:27 GMT
Yes I was sorry about Ashworth. I wonder if they'll find a role for him.
As to PR, I used to quite like the idea but when you see all coalitions constantly falling apart in Europe and the dramatic rise of the right wing, plus the fact that it's taken 6 months to get a govt in the Netherlands, it makes you stop and think.
Brutal as it is, FPTP at least nearly always produces a clear winner.
In sporting terms you wouldn't give Fred the gold medal because he came second 6 times out of 10, you'd give it to Bob because he won on the day.
|
|
skylark
Silver Surfer
Posts: 110
Member is Online
|
Post by skylark on Jul 6, 2024 6:33:23 GMT
I was surprised to find UKIP had a candidate. I thought that was dead and buried. It only raised 144 votes I am happy to say.. We had a couple of independent candidates; one is a former mayor and seems a decent bloke, and the other has worked hard on a local issues but neither qualifies them to be MPs. Stick to what you do best, chaps!
|
|
|
Post by rikiiboy on Jul 7, 2024 10:55:01 GMT
|
|
|
Post by hild1066 on Jul 8, 2024 11:03:43 GMT
I understand that the police in your neck of the woods are investigating concerns that arose around groups of Muslim men filming and shouting at female campaigners for other parties and that one woman out posting leaflets was filmed by a group of men so she could be targeted on social media and then had her tyres slashed.
I get their aggrievement but the ballot box is the place for this and I hope that the police take this seriously and make some arrests.
|
|
|
Post by rikiiboy on Jul 8, 2024 14:27:19 GMT
Do anyone have a clue when Labour will give us their first budget?
|
|
|
Post by marispiper on Jul 10, 2024 11:46:10 GMT
Do anyone have a clue when Labour will give us their first budget? I think there's going to be a few minor announcements but I believe The Budget actual will be in September. That's what I've heard.
|
|
|
Post by rikiiboy on Jul 11, 2024 11:13:54 GMT
|
|
|
Post by marispiper on Jul 11, 2024 16:26:32 GMT
I understand that the police in your neck of the woods are investigating concerns that arose around groups of Muslim men filming and shouting at female campaigners for other parties and that one woman out posting leaflets was filmed by a group of men so she could be targeted on social media and then had her tyres slashed. I get their aggrievement but the ballot box is the place for this and I hope that the police take this seriously and make some arrests. Actually Hildie, I don't get their grievance, in the respect of it having nothing whatsoever to do with UK politics - nor does protest, on any scale or any kind, have any impact whatsoever on either Hamas or Israel. Starmer, or anyone else's support (or otherwise) for either side has but one effect, to cause disrespect, disharmony AND violence here.
|
|
|
Post by marispiper on Jul 12, 2024 8:36:43 GMT
I understand that the police in your neck of the woods are investigating concerns that arose around groups of Muslim men filming and shouting at female campaigners for other parties and that one woman out posting leaflets was filmed by a group of men so she could be targeted on social media and then had her tyres slashed. I get their aggrievement but the ballot box is the place for this and I hope that the police take this seriously and make some arrests. Actually Hildie, I don't get their grievance, in the respect of it having nothing whatsoever to do with UK politics - nor does protest, on any scale or any kind, have any impact whatsoever on either Hamas or Israel. Starmer, or anyone else's support (or otherwise) for either side has but one effect, to cause disrespect, disharmony AND violence here. Now one being investigated regarding terrorist activities. Now why doesn't that surprise me.. Unthinkable that we have such people sitting in the House of Commons! Doubly sad that a 100% decent person like Ashworth lost his seat to this.
|
|
|
Post by hild1066 on Jul 12, 2024 12:16:31 GMT
I meant that I Understand how upset they are about what is happening in Gaza. But their grasp on international law and democracy is very low. No country, UK included can tell Netanyahu what to do in his own country. They can ask, they can cajole, they can threaten sanctions and he may have broken international war crimes legislation but there is not another country that can actually stop him. He has not invaded another country. Gaza is part of Israel. Other countries may not like that but as it is that is the situation today. Egypt will not open it's borders because then Israel will push 2.5 million Palestinians over the border.
He was democratically elected and if the Israeli people want a different person they are free to elect someone else. He is only there via coalition with other parties (bloody PR again). Whereas many of the countries these protestors and harassers are from are not democratic countries, or they are quasi democratic e.g. It has been the same family running Bangladesh for decades and don't get on the wrong side of them.
The campaign for all candidates was dreadful, people had to hide, call the police, receive harassment from groups of men following them and filming them. It was shocking. The police are apparently investigating. Getting 3 or 4 MPs will do nothing at all for their alleged campaign to bring peace to Gaza. They are as powerless today as they were last Thursday morning in relation to that.
There is always lots of hypocrisy around international relations in these areas. Ireland for instance has declared that it will pass legislation to say that Palestine is an independent state. Well, what exactly will that mean? Nothing, unless all the other countries do the same and they won't. Ireland sits of periphery of Europe on an island and it regularly criticises other countries and the stance they take about asylum and immigration and yet when people started coming over their borders they were like - take them away, we haven't got room, we don't have the money- we are going to make the UK take them back. It has always been relatively easy to get in and out of Palestine if you have an Irish passport and people like the IRA have links going back a long way. But if the US doesn't go to the UN and ask for Palestine to be a separate state then it just isn't going to happen.
What we and other countries could have been better at would have been forcing Israel to allow aid in. We can do that by threatening to suspend trade agreements unless they allow a steady supply of aid. Israel are not wrong in saying that Hamas have embedded themselves into the community. Unfortunately the community are in the cross wires.
Could we do more internationally, probably. Should we be looking at all the sports washing going on the in Gulf, yes we should. However, on our own it is pretty meaningless. Although I don't mind it when we do sometimes take a stand. I was always happy that Wilson did not take us into the Vietnam War and not happy that Blair took us into Iraq. We can say no to the US sometimes and we should. It's not a two way street, they said no to us over the Falkands.
Ashworth has secured a job in a Research & Marketing Role for Labour. I think he'll be happy with that and if he wants to he can stand again somewhere.
|
|
|
Post by marispiper on Jul 12, 2024 12:27:49 GMT
Good post Hildie. Actually, pressing for more aid to go in is an achievable aim.
I guess Ashworth might have moved on in one respect. However, doesn't take away that Labour have sadly lost an important front bench member.
We can't say that Labour haven't hit the ground running and action is very refreshing in itself after so many years of inertia 🤣
|
|
|
Post by rikiiboy on Jul 12, 2024 13:26:20 GMT
Hilda, Israel only got possession of that land via GB, they got it because of persecution, that's exactly how they are treating the Palestinians now. They have locked Palestinians up for 57 years, Palestine is not part of Israel and never will be.
There are 5,350,000 Palestinians involved here.
[As of June 2024, the State of Palestine is recognized as a sovereign state by 145 of the 193 member states of the United Nations. It has been a non-member observer state of the United Nations General Assembly since November 2012.]
|
|
|
Post by Hilde on Jul 12, 2024 17:28:57 GMT
You can't change the past though Rikki. I am well aware that Israel is in no way innocent in any of this and its treatment of Palestinians over 70 years is appalling. Beyond appalling. There are even online sites claiming they will be able to build beach side villas in Gaza once the Palestinians are killed or driven out and giving estimates on building costd. There are MPs in the Israeli parliament that believe they should leave or die.
However, I was talking about international law and this does very little to protect people from their own leaders. It also stops other countries intervening apart from humanitarian aid or the supply of arms e.g. Ukraine. In that situation it has taken an alliance of countries to make this happen, but everyone knows that Ukraine was a pretty corrupt country before the war and about a third of the population wanted to be Russian. There will be war crimes on both sides of that conflict too.
I am glad that we haven't got any further involved in either of these conflicts. I also don't think we want half a million Palestinians moving here. We would take years filtering out those who were Hamas or Hamas supporters.
Hamas and Hezbollah act like dictatorships. There is no democracy in Palestine. The ordinary people of Palestine have no choices. We must also remember that about a third are Christian and they are always under pressure from these two groups. They don't mind the Church of England building a hospital or the Catholic Church building a school, but they don't let Christians take part in any kind of govt.
|
|